Ann Rutherford - Actor Profile

Ann Rutherford

Acting
Updated: May 09, 2026
50Total Films
9.0 Highest Rated
Born: Nov 2, 1917
Birth Place: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

About Ann Rutherford

Ann Rutherford was born in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. The daughter of a former Metropolitan Opera singer, John Rutherford, and her actress mother, Lillian Mansfield, Ann was destined for show business. Not long after her birth, her family moved to California, where she made her stage debut in 1925. Ann appeared in many plays and on radio for the next nine years before making her first screen appearance in Waterfront Lady (1935). Ann's talent was readily apparent, and she was signed to three films in 1935: Waterfront Lady (1935), Melody Trail (1935), and The Fighting Marines (1935). By now, she was a leading lady in the fabled Westerns with two legends, John Wayne and Gene Autry. By the time Ann was 17, she inked a deal with MGM, where she would gain the status of superstar for her portrayal of Polly Benedict in the popular Andy Hardy series with Mickey Rooney. Ann's first role as Polly was in 1938, in You're Only Young Once (1937). Three more Hardy films were produced that same year: Out West with the Hardys (1938), Love Finds Andy Hardy (1938), and Judge Hardy's Children (1938). Ann found time to play in other productions, too. One that is still loved today is the Charles Dickens' classic A Christmas Carol (1938), in which she played the sweet role of the Spirit of Christmas Past. In 1939, Ann played the role of Annie Hawks in Of Human Hearts (1938) in addition to three more Andy Hardy films. But that year also saw Ann land a role in the most popular film in film history. She played Careen O'Hara, Scarlett's little sister, in Gone with the Wind (1939). Plenty of fans of the Andy Hardy series went to see it just for Ann. The film was unquestionably a super hit. Ann then resumed making other movies. While working for MGM, Ann, along with the other stars, was under the watchful eye of movie mogul Louis B. Mayer. The bottom line was profit, and Mayer kept performers' salaries minimized as much as possible. Most tried to get raises and failed. Even Mickey Rooney was decidedly underpaid during his glory years at MGM. But not Ann Rutherford. When she asked for a raise, she took out her bankbook and, showing him the amount it contained, told Mayer she had promised her mother a new house. Ann got her raise. In 1942 at the age of 22, Ann appeared in her last Andy Hardy film, Andy Hardy's Double Life (1942). She then left MGM and freelanced her talent. Ann was still in demand. In 1943, she appeared in Happy Land (1943), but it was a little later in her career when she appeared in two big hits. In 1947, she played Gertrude Griswold in The Secret Life of Walter Mitty, and Donna Elena in Adventures of Don Juan in 1948. After that, Ann appeared in several TV programs and didn't return to the silver screen until 1972, in They Only Kill Their Masters (1972). Her last role came in 1976 in the dismal Won Ton Ton: The Dog Who Saved Hollywood (1976), whereupon she retired. Ann was approached to play the older Rose in 1998's mega hit Titanic (1997) but turned it down. She happily enjoyed her retirement being constantly deluged with fan mail and granting several interviews and appearances. Ann Rutherford died at her Beverly Hills home on June 11, 2012 with her close friend Anne Jeffreys by her side. She was 94 years old.

Ann Rutherford Movies & Career Overview

The filmography of Ann Rutherford reflects exceptional commercial consistency. Across 50 major appearances, the actor has built a reputation through performances in multiple genres and storytelling styles.

Dominant Genre

A large portion of Ann Rutherford's work falls within the Comedy genre, where audiences tend to respond most strongly to their on-screen presence.

Success Ratio

Approximately 74% of Ann Rutherford's films maintain ratings above 6.5, indicating a consistent level of audience approval.

One of the most highly rated entries in their career remains Flag of Mercy, which stands out as a key performance.

Advertisement

Best Ann Rutherford Movies Ranked

Must-watch hits from Ann Rutherford's career based on audience ratings.

Full Filmography

Every movie Ann Rutherford has appeared in, with audience ratings and verdicts.

YearMovieCharacterSuccessMore
2009 1939: Hollywood's Greatest Year Self (archive footage) Super Hit Similar →
1988 The Making of a Legend: Gone with the Wind Self Super Hit Similar →
1983 Hollywood Out-takes and Rare Footage Self (archive footage) (uncredited) Hit Similar →
1948 Adventures of Don Juan Donna Elena Hit Similar →
1947 The Secret Life of Walter Mitty Gertrude Griswold Hit Similar →
1946 Inside Job Claire Norton Average Similar →
1946 The Madonna's Secret Linda 'Morgan' North Average Similar →
1945 Two O'Clock Courage Patty Mitchell Average Similar →
1944 Take It or Leave It (archive footage) (uncredited) Average Similar →
1944 Bermuda Mystery Constance Martin Super Hit Similar →
1943 Whistling in Brooklyn Carol Lambert Hit Similar →
1943 Happy Land Lenore Prentiss Hit Similar →
1943 Show-Business at War Self Hit Similar →
1942 Whistling in Dixie Carol Lambert Average Similar →
1942 Orchestra Wives Connie Ward Abbot Hit Similar →
1942 The Courtship of Andy Hardy Polly Benedict Average Similar →
1942 This Time for Keeps Katherine 'Kit' White Super Hit Similar →
1942 Flag of Mercy Clara's Student Super Hit Similar →
1941 Badlands of Dakota Anne Grayson Average Similar →
1941 Life Begins for Andy Hardy Polly Benedict Average Similar →
1941 Washington Melodrama Laurie Claymore Average Similar →
1940 Keeping Company Mary Thomas Hit Similar →
1940 Wyoming Lucy Kincaid Hit Similar →
1940 Cavalcade of the Academy Awards Self Hit Similar →
1940 Pride and Prejudice Lydia Bennet Hit Similar →
1940 Hollywood: Style Center of the World Self Average Similar →
1940 Andy Hardy's Dilemma: A Lesson in Mathematics... and Other Things Polly Benedict (uncredited) Super Hit Similar →
1939 Gone with the Wind Carreen O'Hara Super Hit Similar →
1939 Dancing Co-Ed Eve Greeley Hit Similar →
1939 Angel of Mercy Sister of Dead Soldier (uncredited) Super Hit Similar →
1939 The Hardys Ride High Polly Benedict Hit Similar →
1939 Four Girls in White Patricia 'Pat' Page Hit Similar →
1938 A Christmas Carol Spirit of Christmas Past Hit Similar →
1938 Dramatic School Yvonne Hit Similar →
1938 Out West with the Hardys Polly Benedict Hit Similar →
1938 Love Finds Andy Hardy Polly Benedict Average Similar →
1938 Judge Hardy's Children Polly Benedict Hit Similar →
1937 The Bride Wore Red Third Peasant Girl (uncredited) Hit Similar →
1937 The Devil Is Driving Kitty Wooster Hit Similar →
1937 Public Cowboy No. 1 Helen Morgan Average Similar →
1937 Carnival in Paris Lisette Super Hit Similar →
1937 Espionage Train Passenger Hit Similar →
1936 Annie Laurie Annie Laurie Average Similar →
1936 The Harvester Ruth Jameson Super Hit Similar →
1936 Comin' 'Round the Mountain Dolores Moreno Super Hit Similar →
1936 Doughnuts and Society Joan Dugan Super Hit Similar →
1936 The Oregon Trail Anne Ridgeley Hit Similar →
1935 The Singing Vagabond Lettie Morgan Super Hit Similar →
1935 The Fighting Marines Frances Schiller Hit Similar →
1934 Student Tour Student Hit Similar →

Ann Rutherford - Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best movie of Ann Rutherford?

According to audience ratings, the best movie starring Ann Rutherford is "Flag of Mercy" with a rating of 9.0/10.

How many movies has Ann Rutherford acted in?

Ann Rutherford has been featured in at least 50 major films throughout their career.

What are some other popular movies by Ann Rutherford?

Other notable films include "Comin' 'Round the Mountain", "The Harvester", and "The Making of a Legend: Gone with the Wind".

Advertisement