Dynamic Watchlist Hub: Jan 13, 2026

10 Best Movies Like Once Upon a Time in Sicily

If you loved Once Upon a Time in Sicily, we've curated the perfect watchlist for you based on shared genres, themes, and directorial style.

🏆

Expert Review & Ratings

See our full critical analysis and audience score for Once Upon a Time in Sicily.

View Review →
#1
Sapphire Blue

Sapphire Blue

2014★ 7.1

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Drama. It captures a similar emotionally gripping atmosphere.

Gwen has just discovered, that she's the final member of the secret time-traveling Circle of Twelve. Now she has to juggle with constant trips to the past, her relationships with G...

#2
American Pie Presents: The Book of Love

American Pie Presents: The Book of Love

2009★ 5.3

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Comedy. It captures a similar light-hearted atmosphere.

Ten years after the first American Pie movie, three new hapless virgins discover the Bible hidden in the school library at East Great Falls High. Unfortunately for them, the book i...

#3
Return of the Living Dead Part II

Return of the Living Dead Part II

1988★ 6.4

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

A group of kids discover one of the drums containing a rotting corpse and release the 2-4-5 Trioxin gas into the air, causing the dead to once again rise from the grave and seek ou...

#4
Return of the Tooth Fairy

Return of the Tooth Fairy

2020★ 6.5

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

The Tooth Fairy is back. 15 years after the events of the first movie, Corey, now grown up but mentally scarred has gone to a class reunion. However, the Tooth Fairy is back, and t...

#5
Scooby-Doo! and the Pirates

Scooby-Doo! and the Pirates

2011★ 9.5

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Animation. It captures a similar light-hearted atmosphere.

Splash into action with seafaring sleuths Scooby-Doo and the Mystery, Inc. gang as they collide with a mystery ship and try to uncover clues from a vanished crew in Hassle in the C...

#6
I could have been offended!

I could have been offended!

2001★ 6.7

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Once Upon a Time in Sicily for fans of Comedy. It captures a similar light-hearted atmosphere.

Live stage recording of the stand-up comedy show, with sketches and videos of old skits from 'Mai dire Gol'....