Pony Soldier backdrop - movieMx Review
Pony Soldier movie poster - Pony Soldier review and rating on movieMx
195282 minWestern

Pony Soldier

Is Pony Soldier a Hit or Flop?

FLOP

Is Pony Soldier worth watching? With a rating of 5.9/10, this Western film is a mixed-bag for fans of the genre. Read on for our detailed analysis and user reviews.

5.926 votes
RateYour rating
Advertisement

Pony Soldier Synopsis

Duncan MacDonald, a 19th-century Royal Canadian Mountie, has to escort a group of Cree Indians back to their above-the-border reservation. His guide in this endeavor is the not-too-trustworthy half-breed Natayo.

Advertisement

Top Cast

Tyrone Power
Tyrone PowerConstable Duncan MacDonald
Cameron Mitchell
Cameron MitchellKonah
Thomas Gomez
Thomas GomezNatayo Smith
Penny Edwards
Penny EdwardsEmerald Neeley
Robert Horton
Robert HortonJess Calhoun
Anthony Earl Numkena
Anthony Earl NumkenaComes Running (as Anthony Earl Numkena)
Adeline De Walt Reynolds
Adeline De Walt ReynoldsWhite Moon (as Adeline DeWalt Reynolds)
Howard Petrie
Howard PetrieInsp. Frazer
Stuart Randall
Stuart RandallStanding Bear
Earl Holliman
Earl HollimanUndetermined Secondary Role (uncredited)

Official Trailer

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pony Soldier worth watching?

Pony Soldier has received mixed reviews with a 5.9/10 rating. It might be worth watching if you're a fan of Western movies.

Is Pony Soldier hit or flop?

Pony Soldier has received average ratings (5.9/10), performing moderately with audiences.

What genre is Pony Soldier?

Pony Soldier is a Western movie that Duncan MacDonald, a 19th-century Royal Canadian Mountie, has to escort a group of Cree Indians back to their above-the-border reservation. His guide i...

You Might Also Like

Explore More

Critic Reviews

CinemaSerfFeb 13, 2023
★ 6

Tyrone Power is the new RCMP officer with good Scots antecedence "Duncan MacDonald" who is charged with rescuing two hostages who have been taken prisoner by the raiding Cree from Montana. With only his untrustworthy scout "Natayo" (Thomas Gomez) to help, he has deal with Cameron Mitchell's warmongering ("Konah") and his proud tribesmen and try to come to peaceable terms before an all out war begins. Now the obvious criticism has to be the location photography - Arizona is certainly not northern Montana nor Saskatchewan, and that rather sums up the fairly hung-go historical aspects of the story. That said, though, once the adventure hots up then Power imposes himself on the screen and it livens up a bit. Of course one of the hostages "Emerald" (Penny Edwards) has to provide an element of love interest, which rather drags the thing down, but it's still quite a colourful and entertaining enough vehicle for the star to be just that, for the writing and story to be largely ignored and for it all to end entirely predictably. Not great, not even good - but it has enough bow and arrow action to keep it interesting.