Dynamic Watchlist Hub: May 16, 2026

10 Best Movies Like The Brotherhood

If you loved The Brotherhood, we've curated the perfect watchlist for you based on shared genres, themes, and directorial style.

🏆

Expert Review & Ratings

See our full critical analysis and audience score for The Brotherhood.

View Review →
Advertisement
#1
Night Teeth

Night Teeth

2021★ 6.4

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

A college student moonlighting as a chauffeur picks up two mysterious women for a night of party-hopping across LA. But when he uncovers their bloodthirsty intentions—and their dan...

#2
Insidious: The Red Door

Insidious: The Red Door

2023★ 6.5

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

To put their demons to rest once and for all, Josh Lambert and a college-aged Dalton Lambert must go deeper into The Further than ever before, facing their family's dark past and a...

#3
Lust for a Vampire

Lust for a Vampire

1971★ 5.8

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

In 1830, the Karnstein heirs use the blood of an innocent to bring forth the evil that is the beautiful Mircalla - or as she was in 1710, Carmilla. The nearby Finishing School offe...

#4
Happy Birthday to Me

Happy Birthday to Me

1981★ 6.0

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

Virginia is proud that she belongs to a clique. The best students at a private school. But before her 18th birthday, a gruesome set of murders take place and her friends are the on...

#5
Slaughter High

Slaughter High

1986★ 5.8

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

Eight different people are invited to their 10-year high school reunion at their now-closed down high school where a former student, disfigured from a prank gone wrong, is there to...

#6
Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II

Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II

1987★ 6.1

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to The Brotherhood for fans of Horror. It captures a similar spine-chilling atmosphere.

When Hamilton High’s Prom Queen of 1957, Mary Lou Maloney, is killed by her jilted boyfriend, she comes back for revenge thirty years later....

Advertisement